Opinion
Reels don't run a state: the TVK government must answer for its governance record
A viral smartphone video is not a substitute for governance. As the Tamil Nadu government leans on social-media optics, its record on jobs, fiscal health and service delivery deserves hard scrutiny.
The smartphone has become the Tamil Nadu government's favourite policy instrument. A clip goes viral, the comments fill with fire emojis, and for a news cycle the administration basks in the glow of digital applause. But reels do not run a state. Behind the filters lies a governance record that deserves far harder scrutiny than a 30-second vertical video can provide.
Take jobs. The state's much-touted employment numbers rest heavily on informal and gig work, while educated youth continue to queue for government posts that never materialise. The TVK government inherited this crisis; it has not solved it. Announcements of skilling missions and job fairs make for good content, but placement data — where it exists at all — tells a thinner story.
Then there is the fiscal picture. Tamil Nadu's debt has climbed steadily, and committed expenditure on salaries, pensions and interest now consumes the lion's share of revenue. Welfare announcements play well on camera, but every new scheme launched for the timeline tightens the fiscal vice. The government rarely subjects its numbers to independent audit in public view.
Service delivery tells a similar tale. In Chennai's suburbs and the state's smaller towns, residents still battle waterlogging every monsoon, patchy garbage collection and overcrowded public hospitals. These are unglamorous problems that do not trend. Fixing a stormwater drain will never get the views that a minister's dance challenge does — but it is the actual job.
None of this is to say communication does not matter. Every modern government must speak the language of the platforms where citizens live. The problem is substitution: when optics replace outcomes as the measure of success, accountability dies in the comments section.
The TVK came to power promising a break from the Dravidian majors' style of governance. That promise is now being tested not on Instagram but in budget documents, employment exchanges and municipal wards. Voters who thrilled to the campaign's energy deserve a government that governs as energetically as it posts.
The measure of this administration will not be its follower count. It will be whether a young graduate in Madurai finds dignified work, whether a farmer in Thanjavur gets water on time, and whether the state's finances can sustain the promises made on screen. On those counts, the government must answer — in the assembly, in white papers, and in results. Not in reels.
Sources
Share this story
Related articles

Opinion: In Tigray, the Gulf powers are playing chess while civilians pay the price
The UAE's loud backing of Addis Ababa and Saudi Arabia's studied silence are not peacemaking but positioning. Judge the Gulf powers by outcomes in Tigray, not communiques.
· 3 min read

Opinion: A meditation hall is not a security threat
The Madras High Court was right to demand honest disclosure under FCRA. It was wrong to grade religions from the Bench. The state may regulate conduct; it must never rank faiths.
· 2 min read

Opinion: When the umpire will not meet the players, the match itself is in doubt
An opposition trimmed to ten names still cannot get a presidential appointment, and a Dalit leader's question about Tamil Nadu's roll will not go away. Democracy needs a referee who answers.
· 2 min read

Opinion: A fan that stops at noon, a wage that never arrives - the dignity test the state keeps failing
In Chennai the fan stops at 9am. In Jammu the wage stops at Rs 8,000. Periyar asked who bears the burden, Anna asked whether work carries dignity. By that measure, the modern state still publishes notices where it should publish justice.
· 2 min read