00:00 IST 31°C

Opinion

The camera is the first casualty: a government that deletes videos is writing its own confession

First the cash-for-votes charge, now a seized phone and deleted footage: the Dharapuram bypoll is exposing the TVK's intolerance of scrutiny. Power that fears the lens fears the people.

By The Justice news desk

· 2 min read

News microphones at a press conference (editorial illustration)
Editorial illustration: the press at work. When a government seizes the camera, it seizes the people's witness. Photo: Domzalee / Wikimedia Commons
There is an old rule of power: watch what a government does to the camera. Everything else is public relations. Two days before the Dharapuram by-election, the BJP's Nainar Nagenthran alleged that TVK functionaries seized a journalist's mobile phone and forcibly deleted the videos he had filmed of them. Consider what that means. The instrument was not smashed in anger; it was confiscated and wiped with purpose. Someone looked at the footage, decided the public must not see it, and pressed delete. That is not the behaviour of a movement confident in its conduct. It is the behaviour of people with something to hide, or people who have learned that hiding works. The TVK arrived promising to be the clean break: young, unsullied, the 'pure force' against the 'evil force' of the old order, in the Chief Minister's own campaign language. But purity is not a slogan; it is a practice, and the practice on display in Dharapuram is depressingly familiar. A journalist films. The cadres surround him. The phone is taken. The record is erased. Tamil Nadu has seen this film before, under governments of every colour. The tragedy is that the party which promised to end the rerun is now directing it. And it is not an isolated frame. In the same bypoll, the NTK's Karthika has alleged cash and gift distribution by TVK workers and questioned the impartiality of election officials. Weeks earlier, a YouTuber was arrested over comments on the Karur stampede tragedy that killed 41 people. The pattern is not subtle: scrutiny is treated as hostility, and hostility is treated as a crime. Periyar taught that power must be questioned precisely when it claims to be beyond question, when it wraps itself in purity, in youth, in the romance of the new. A government that deletes videos is not protecting its dignity; it is confessing its fear. The camera is the people's witness, the one instrument that lets a citizen in a village see what the powerful did when they thought no one important was watching. Take the camera, and you take the witness. Delete the video, and you delete the people from the record. The TVK's defenders will say the allegation comes from the BJP, a party with no moral standing on press freedom. True, and irrelevant. The messenger's hypocrisy does not clean the message's stain. If the allegation is false, the TVK should welcome an inquiry and clear its name. If it is true, no denunciation of the BJP will undelete those videos. Dharapuram votes on October 6. The voters will decide many things. But one question is already answered: a movement that fears the lens has told us exactly how it intends to govern, in the dark, with the record wiped clean.

Sources

Share this story

AMP

Related articles