Opinion: The empty chair in the agriculture secretariat is a policy, and farmers are paying for it
A month after the Agriculture Secretary was transferred, Tamil Nadu still has no full-time replacement, even as the Cauvery delivers its lowest flow in 14 years and the samba season stalls. An empty chair at the top is not an oversight; it is a choice.
There is a chair in the Tamil Nadu agriculture secretariat that has now been empty, in any full-time sense, for a month. The officer who held the Agriculture and Farmers Welfare Secretary's post was transferred to archaeology, and no dedicated successor has been appointed since. This week the opposition leader Udhayanidhi Stalin asked the obvious question in public: how does a state with a separate agriculture budget run its farm department without a full-time secretary, with the monsoon at the door?
Governments like to present vacancies as paperwork. Farmers experience them as weather. A secretary is the officer who turns a minister's announcement into a district-level instruction: who releases water and when, who verifies a failed crop, who signs the compensation file, who answers when a tail-end canal runs dry. Remove that officer for a month and every one of those decisions slows down, drifts, or quietly dies in a file. In a normal season that is inefficiency. In this season it is something worse.
Consider what this particular month contained. Tamil Nadu recorded its lowest Cauvery realisation in 14 years. Kuruvai cultivation in Nagapattinam collapsed from about 30,000 hectares to roughly 1,720. Samba, the main season, had begun on barely 20,000 of a targeted 3.12 lakh acres in the delta reports, with tail-end farmers still waiting for water. Fine rice rose about 20% in a month. In Muthupettai, farmers blocked a road because irrigation water never reached the tail end. And through all of it, the department responsible for responding had no full-time head. The ruling TVK government, which came to office promising change, has still not delivered the crop-loan waiver it promised, a point the opposition pressed this week alongside the vacancy.
A government reveals its priorities not in its speeches but in its postings. A chief minister who can find time for roadshows and reels can find an officer for agriculture; the Indian Administrative Service is not short of names. Leaving the chair empty for a month, in the exact weeks when the delta needed its fastest decisions in over a decade, tells farmers where they rank. The Periyarist tradition this paper carries has a simple test for any regime: judge it by the last person in the queue. By that test, the farmer at the tail end of a dry canal, waiting for water, compensation and a secretary who does not exist, has already delivered the verdict.
The remedy costs nothing and requires no new law: appoint a full-time Agriculture Secretary today, publish a samba water-and-compensation calendar with dates, and report weekly on tail-end delivery until the season closes. If the government does that, this column will happily record it. Until then, the empty chair remains the most honest statement of policy the TVK government has made.